Cal Corum 4cadb6566c CLAUDE: Clean up stale TODO comments from Phase 3E completion

Removed outdated TODO comments and updated documentation to reflect
work completed in Phase 3E (Position Ratings and WebSocket Handlers).

Changes:
- Removed 2 stale WebSocket emission TODOs in game_engine.py (lines 319, 387)
  These referenced Phase 3E-Final work completed on 2025-01-10
- Updated backend/CLAUDE.md Phase 3E status section
  Marked defender retrieval as COMPLETE (Phase 3E-Main)
  Clarified SPD test still pending (needs batter speed rating)
  Marked runner advancement as COMPLETE (Phase 3D)
- Updated TODO_RESOLUTION_SUMMARY.md
  Marked defender lookup TODO as resolved with implementation details

Documentation:
- Created TODO_AUDIT_2025-01-14.md - Complete TODO audit (53 items)
- Created TODO_VERIFICATION_RESULTS.md - Verification of resolved items
- Created TODO_SUMMARY.md - Quick reference priority matrix
- Created TODO_CLEANUP_COMPLETE.md - Cleanup work summary

Test Status:
- Backend: 9/9 PlayResolver tests passing
- No regressions introduced

Remaining Work:
- 41 legitimate TODOs properly categorized for future phases
- 8 Phase F6 TODOs (game page integration)
- 5 Quick win TODOs (optional polish)
- 28 Future phase TODOs (auth, AI, advanced features)

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>

2025-11-14 08:12:08 -06:00

2.5 KiB

Raw Blame History

TODO Summary - Quick Reference

Date: 2025-01-14 Status: Post-Phase F5, Pre-Phase F6

Quick Stats

Category	Count	Priority
Stale Comments (already done)	12	Clean up now
Phase F6 (game integration)	8	Next sprint
Quick Wins (optional polish)	5	Optional
Future Phases (F7+, Phase 4, Week 9)	28	Defer
TOTAL	53	-

Priority Matrix

🔴 Priority 1: Clean Up Now (30 min)

Already completed - just remove comments

12 stale TODOs:

2 WebSocket emission comments (game_engine.py)
Position ratings documentation update (CLAUDE.md)
Defender lookup verification
Update TODO_RESOLUTION_SUMMARY.md

Why Now: Avoid confusion, accurate documentation

🟡 Priority 2: Phase F6 Integration (6-8 hours)

Critical for game lobby system

8 TODOs:

Backend (3): Game API endpoints (list/get/create)
Frontend (5): Game page integration, lobby UI

Why F6: Core workflow for creating/joining games

🟢 Priority 3: Quick Wins (1 hour)

Optional code polish

5 TODOs:

Remove unused config fields (strikes_for_out, balls_for_walk)
Clean up outcome arrays
Fix toast positioning
Test data improvements
Method naming refactor

Why Optional: Nice to have, not blocking

⚪ Priority 4: Future Phases (Defer)

Not MVP critical

28 TODOs:

Authorization (10): WebSocket auth checks → Phase F7+
Authentication (2): Discord OAuth → Phase F7+
AI Opponent (6): Decision-making logic → Week 9
Advanced Gameplay (5): Uncapped hits, interactive decisions → Phase 4+
SPD Test (1): Batter speed rating → Phase 3E-Final or F6
Rare Play (3): Define RP logic or accept placeholder → Decide
Statistics (1): Earned runs calculation → Future

Why Defer: MVP works without these, add value later

Detailed Breakdown

See full documents:

TODO_AUDIT_2025-01-14.md - Complete audit with context
TODO_VERIFICATION_RESULTS.md - Verification of resolved vs pending

Recommended Next Actions

✅ Done: TODO audit and verification complete
Next: Clean up 12 stale TODOs (~30 min)
Then: Proceed with Phase F6 integration (8 TODOs, 6-8 hours)
Optional: Quick wins if time permits (5 TODOs, 1 hour)

Cal's Decision Point:

Start with Priority 1 cleanup now? (30 min)
Skip cleanup and go straight to Phase F6? (your call)
Do quick wins first? (optional 1 hour)

2.5 KiB Raw Blame History