● Terminal Client Improvement Plan - Part 2: Robust Argument Parsing

  Overview

  Replace manual string splitting with shlex for robust argument parsing that handles quoted strings, edge cases, and
  complex arguments properly.

  Files to Create

  1. Create backend/terminal_client/arg_parser.py

  """
  Argument parsing utilities for terminal client commands.

  Provides robust parsing for both REPL and CLI commands using shlex
  to handle quoted strings, spaces, and complex arguments.

  Author: Claude
  Date: 2025-10-27
  """
  import shlex
  import logging
  from typing import Dict, Any, List, Optional, Tuple

  logger = logging.getLogger(f'{__name__}.arg_parser')


  class ArgumentParseError(Exception):
      """Raised when argument parsing fails."""
      pass


  class CommandArgumentParser:
      """Parse command-line style arguments for terminal client."""

      @staticmethod
      def parse_args(arg_string: str, schema: Dict[str, Any]) -> Dict[str, Any]:
          """
          Parse argument string according to schema.
          
          Args:
              arg_string: Raw argument string from command
              schema: Dictionary defining expected arguments
                  {
                      'league': {'type': str, 'default': 'sba'},
                      'home-team': {'type': int, 'default': 1},
                      'count': {'type': int, 'default': 1, 'positional': True},
                      'verbose': {'type': bool, 'flag': True}
                  }
          
          Returns:
              Dictionary of parsed arguments with defaults applied
              
          Raises:
              ArgumentParseError: If parsing fails or validation fails
          """
          try:
              # Use shlex for robust parsing
              tokens = shlex.split(arg_string) if arg_string.strip() else []
          except ValueError as e:
              raise ArgumentParseError(f"Invalid argument syntax: {e}")

          # Initialize result with defaults
          result = {}
          for key, spec in schema.items():
              if 'default' in spec:
                  result[key] = spec['default']

          # Track which positional arg we're on
          positional_keys = [k for k, v in schema.items() if v.get('positional', False)]
          positional_index = 0

          i = 0
          while i < len(tokens):
              token = tokens[i]

              # Handle flags (--option or -o)
              if token.startswith('--'):
                  option_name = token[2:]

                  # Convert hyphen to underscore for Python compatibility
                  option_key = option_name.replace('-', '_')

                  if option_key not in schema:
                      raise ArgumentParseError(f"Unknown option: {token}")

                  spec = schema[option_key]

                  # Boolean flags don't need a value
                  if spec.get('flag', False):
                      result[option_key] = True
                      i += 1
                      continue

                  # Option requires a value
                  if i + 1 >= len(tokens):
                      raise ArgumentParseError(f"Option {token} requires a value")

                  value_str = tokens[i + 1]

                  # Type conversion
                  try:
                      if spec['type'] == int:
                          result[option_key] = int(value_str)
                      elif spec['type'] == float:
                          result[option_key] = float(value_str)
                      elif spec['type'] == list:
                          # Parse comma-separated list
                          result[option_key] = [item.strip() for item in value_str.split(',')]
                      elif spec['type'] == 'int_list':
                          # Parse comma-separated integers
                          result[option_key] = [int(item.strip()) for item in value_str.split(',')]
                      else:
                          result[option_key] = value_str
                  except ValueError as e:
                      raise ArgumentParseError(
                          f"Invalid value for {token}: expected {spec['type'].__name__}, got '{value_str}'"
                      )

                  i += 2

              # Handle positional arguments
              else:
                  if positional_index >= len(positional_keys):
                      raise ArgumentParseError(f"Unexpected positional argument: {token}")

                  key = positional_keys[positional_index]
                  spec = schema[key]

                  try:
                      if spec['type'] == int:
                          result[key] = int(token)
                      elif spec['type'] == float:
                          result[key] = float(token)
                      else:
                          result[key] = token
                  except ValueError as e:
                      raise ArgumentParseError(
                          f"Invalid value for {key}: expected {spec['type'].__name__}, got '{token}'"
                      )

                  positional_index += 1
                  i += 1

          return result

      @staticmethod
      def parse_game_id(arg_string: str) -> Optional[str]:
          """
          Parse a game ID from argument string.
          
          Args:
              arg_string: Raw argument string
              
          Returns:
              Game ID string or None
          """
          try:
              tokens = shlex.split(arg_string) if arg_string.strip() else []

              # Look for --game-id option
              for i, token in enumerate(tokens):
                  if token == '--game-id' and i + 1 < len(tokens):
                      return tokens[i + 1]

              # If no option, check if there's a positional UUID-like argument
              if tokens and len(tokens[0]) == 36:  # UUID length
                  return tokens[0]

              return None

          except ValueError:
              return None


  # Predefined schemas for common commands
  NEW_GAME_SCHEMA = {
      'league': {'type': str, 'default': 'sba'},
      'home_team': {'type': int, 'default': 1},
      'away_team': {'type': int, 'default': 2}
  }

  DEFENSIVE_SCHEMA = {
      'alignment': {'type': str, 'default': 'normal'},
      'infield': {'type': str, 'default': 'normal'},
      'outfield': {'type': str, 'default': 'normal'},
      'hold': {'type': 'int_list', 'default': []}
  }

  OFFENSIVE_SCHEMA = {
      'approach': {'type': str, 'default': 'normal'},
      'steal': {'type': 'int_list', 'default': []},
      'hit_run': {'type': bool, 'flag': True, 'default': False},
      'bunt': {'type': bool, 'flag': True, 'default': False}
  }

  QUICK_PLAY_SCHEMA = {
      'count': {'type': int, 'default': 1, 'positional': True}
  }

  USE_GAME_SCHEMA = {
      'game_id': {'type': str, 'positional': True}
  }


  def parse_new_game_args(arg_string: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
      """Parse arguments for new_game command."""
      return CommandArgumentParser.parse_args(arg_string, NEW_GAME_SCHEMA)


  def parse_defensive_args(arg_string: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
      """Parse arguments for defensive command."""
      return CommandArgumentParser.parse_args(arg_string, DEFENSIVE_SCHEMA)


  def parse_offensive_args(arg_string: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
      """Parse arguments for offensive command."""
      return CommandArgumentParser.parse_args(arg_string, OFFENSIVE_SCHEMA)


  def parse_quick_play_args(arg_string: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
      """Parse arguments for quick_play command."""
      return CommandArgumentParser.parse_args(arg_string, QUICK_PLAY_SCHEMA)


  def parse_use_game_args(arg_string: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
      """Parse arguments for use_game command."""
      return CommandArgumentParser.parse_args(arg_string, USE_GAME_SCHEMA)

  Files to Update

  2. Update backend/terminal_client/repl.py

  # Add import at top
  from terminal_client.arg_parser import (
      parse_new_game_args,
      parse_defensive_args,
      parse_offensive_args,
      parse_quick_play_args,
      parse_use_game_args,
      ArgumentParseError
  )

  # Replace do_new_game method:
  def do_new_game(self, arg):
      """
      Create a new game with lineups and start it.
      
      Usage: new_game [--league sba|pd] [--home-team N] [--away-team N]
      
      Examples:
        new_game
        new_game --league pd
        new_game --home-team 5 --away-team 3
      """
      async def _new_game():
          try:
              # Parse arguments with robust parser
              args = parse_new_game_args(arg)

              # Use shared command
              gid, success = await game_commands.create_new_game(
                  league=args['league'],
                  home_team=args['home_team'],
                  away_team=args['away_team'],
                  set_current=True
              )

              if success:
                  self.current_game_id = gid

          except ArgumentParseError as e:
              display.print_error(f"Invalid arguments: {e}")
          except Exception as e:
              display.print_error(f"Failed to create game: {e}")
              logger.exception("New game error")

      self._run_async(_new_game())

  # Replace do_defensive method:
  def do_defensive(self, arg):
      """
      Submit defensive decision.
      
      Usage: defensive [--alignment TYPE] [--infield DEPTH] [--outfield DEPTH] [--hold BASES]
      
      Options:
        --alignment    normal, shifted_left, shifted_right, extreme_shift
        --infield      in, normal, back, double_play
        --outfield     in, normal, back
        --hold         Comma-separated bases (e.g., 1,3)
      
      Examples:
        defensive
        defensive --alignment shifted_left
        defensive --infield double_play --hold 1,3
      """
      async def _defensive():
          try:
              gid = self._ensure_game()
              await self._ensure_game_loaded(gid)

              # Parse arguments
              args = parse_defensive_args(arg)

              # Submit decision
              await game_commands.submit_defensive_decision(
                  game_id=gid,
                  alignment=args['alignment'],
                  infield=args['infield'],
                  outfield=args['outfield'],
                  hold_runners=args['hold']
              )

          except ArgumentParseError as e:
              display.print_error(f"Invalid arguments: {e}")
          except ValueError:
              pass  # Already printed error
          except Exception as e:
              display.print_error(f"Failed: {e}")
              logger.exception("Defensive error")

      self._run_async(_defensive())

  # Replace do_offensive method:
  def do_offensive(self, arg):
      """
      Submit offensive decision.
      
      Usage: offensive [--approach TYPE] [--steal BASES] [--hit-run] [--bunt]
      
      Options:
        --approach     normal, contact, power, patient
        --steal        Comma-separated bases (e.g., 2,3)
        --hit-run      Enable hit-and-run (flag)
        --bunt         Attempt bunt (flag)
      
      Examples:
        offensive
        offensive --approach power
        offensive --steal 2 --hit-run
      """
      async def _offensive():
          try:
              gid = self._ensure_game()
              await self._ensure_game_loaded(gid)

              # Parse arguments
              args = parse_offensive_args(arg)

              # Submit decision
              await game_commands.submit_offensive_decision(
                  game_id=gid,
                  approach=args['approach'],
                  steal_attempts=args['steal'],
                  hit_and_run=args['hit_run'],
                  bunt_attempt=args['bunt']
              )

          except ArgumentParseError as e:
              display.print_error(f"Invalid arguments: {e}")
          except ValueError:
              pass
          except Exception as e:
              display.print_error(f"Failed: {e}")
              logger.exception("Offensive error")

      self._run_async(_offensive())

  # Replace do_quick_play method:
  def do_quick_play(self, arg):
      """
      Auto-play multiple plays with default decisions.
      
      Usage: quick_play [COUNT]
      
      Examples:
        quick_play        # Play 1 play
        quick_play 10     # Play 10 plays
        quick_play 27     # Play ~3 innings
      """
      async def _quick_play():
          try:
              gid = self._ensure_game()
              await self._ensure_game_loaded(gid)

              # Parse arguments
              args = parse_quick_play_args(arg)

              # Execute quick play
              plays_completed = await game_commands.quick_play_rounds(
                  game_id=gid,
                  count=args['count']
              )

              display.print_success(f"Completed {plays_completed} plays")

          except ArgumentParseError as e:
              display.print_error(f"Invalid arguments: {e}")
          except ValueError:
              pass
          except Exception as e:
              display.print_error(f"Failed: {e}")
              logger.exception("Quick play error")

      self._run_async(_quick_play())

  # Replace do_use_game method:
  def do_use_game(self, arg):
      """
      Switch to a different game.
      
      Usage: use_game <game_id>
      
      Example:
        use_game a1b2c3d4-e5f6-7890-abcd-ef1234567890
      """
      try:
          # Parse arguments
          args = parse_use_game_args(arg)

          gid = UUID(args['game_id'])
          self.current_game_id = gid
          Config.set_current_game(gid)
          display.print_success(f"Switched to game: {gid}")

      except ArgumentParseError as e:
          display.print_error(f"Invalid arguments: {e}")
      except ValueError:
          display.print_error(f"Invalid UUID: {arg}")

  Testing Plan

  3. Create backend/tests/unit/terminal_client/test_arg_parser.py

  """
  Unit tests for argument parser.
  """
  import pytest

  from terminal_client.arg_parser import (
      CommandArgumentParser,
      ArgumentParseError,
      parse_new_game_args,
      parse_defensive_args,
      parse_offensive_args
  )


  class TestCommandArgumentParser:
      """Tests for CommandArgumentParser."""

      def test_parse_simple_string_arg(self):
          """Test parsing simple string argument."""
          schema = {'name': {'type': str, 'default': 'default'}}
          result = CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('--name test', schema)
          assert result['name'] == 'test'

      def test_parse_integer_arg(self):
          """Test parsing integer argument."""
          schema = {'count': {'type': int, 'default': 1}}
          result = CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('--count 42', schema)
          assert result['count'] == 42

      def test_parse_flag_arg(self):
          """Test parsing boolean flag."""
          schema = {
              'verbose': {'type': bool, 'flag': True, 'default': False}
          }
          result = CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('--verbose', schema)
          assert result['verbose'] is True

      def test_parse_int_list(self):
          """Test parsing comma-separated integer list."""
          schema = {'bases': {'type': 'int_list', 'default': []}}
          result = CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('--bases 1,2,3', schema)
          assert result['bases'] == [1, 2, 3]

      def test_parse_quoted_string(self):
          """Test parsing quoted string with spaces."""
          schema = {'message': {'type': str, 'default': ''}}
          result = CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('--message "hello world"', schema)
          assert result['message'] == 'hello world'

      def test_parse_positional_arg(self):
          """Test parsing positional argument."""
          schema = {
              'count': {'type': int, 'positional': True, 'default': 1}
          }
          result = CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('10', schema)
          assert result['count'] == 10

      def test_parse_mixed_args(self):
          """Test parsing mix of options and positional."""
          schema = {
              'count': {'type': int, 'positional': True, 'default': 1},
              'league': {'type': str, 'default': 'sba'}
          }
          result = CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('5 --league pd', schema)
          assert result['count'] == 5
          assert result['league'] == 'pd'

      def test_parse_unknown_option_raises(self):
          """Test that unknown option raises error."""
          schema = {'name': {'type': str, 'default': 'default'}}
          with pytest.raises(ArgumentParseError, match="Unknown option"):
              CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('--invalid test', schema)

      def test_parse_missing_value_raises(self):
          """Test that missing value for option raises error."""
          schema = {'name': {'type': str, 'default': 'default'}}
          with pytest.raises(ArgumentParseError, match="requires a value"):
              CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('--name', schema)

      def test_parse_invalid_type_raises(self):
          """Test that invalid type conversion raises error."""
          schema = {'count': {'type': int, 'default': 1}}
          with pytest.raises(ArgumentParseError, match="expected int"):
              CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('--count abc', schema)

      def test_parse_empty_string(self):
          """Test parsing empty string returns defaults."""
          schema = {
              'name': {'type': str, 'default': 'default'},
              'count': {'type': int, 'default': 1}
          }
          result = CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('', schema)
          assert result['name'] == 'default'
          assert result['count'] == 1

      def test_parse_hyphen_to_underscore(self):
          """Test that hyphens in options convert to underscores."""
          schema = {'home_team': {'type': int, 'default': 1}}
          result = CommandArgumentParser.parse_args('--home-team 5', schema)
          assert result['home_team'] == 5


  class TestPrebuiltParsers:
      """Tests for pre-built parser functions."""

      def test_parse_new_game_args_defaults(self):
          """Test new_game parser with defaults."""
          result = parse_new_game_args('')
          assert result['league'] == 'sba'
          assert result['home_team'] == 1
          assert result['away_team'] == 2

      def test_parse_new_game_args_custom(self):
          """Test new_game parser with custom values."""
          result = parse_new_game_args('--league pd --home-team 5 --away-team 3')
          assert result['league'] == 'pd'
          assert result['home_team'] == 5
          assert result['away_team'] == 3

      def test_parse_defensive_args_defaults(self):
          """Test defensive parser with defaults."""
          result = parse_defensive_args('')
          assert result['alignment'] == 'normal'
          assert result['infield'] == 'normal'
          assert result['outfield'] == 'normal'
          assert result['hold'] == []

      def test_parse_defensive_args_with_hold(self):
          """Test defensive parser with hold runners."""
          result = parse_defensive_args('--alignment shifted_left --hold 1,3')
          assert result['alignment'] == 'shifted_left'
          assert result['hold'] == [1, 3]

      def test_parse_offensive_args_flags(self):
          """Test offensive parser with flags."""
          result = parse_offensive_args('--approach power --hit-run --bunt')
          assert result['approach'] == 'power'
          assert result['hit_run'] is True
          assert result['bunt'] is True

      def test_parse_offensive_args_steal(self):
          """Test offensive parser with steal attempts."""
          result = parse_offensive_args('--steal 2,3')
          assert result['steal'] == [2, 3]

  Benefits of Improved Parsing

  1. Handles quoted strings: --message "double steal attempt" works correctly
  2. Better error messages: Clear feedback on what went wrong
  3. Type validation: Automatic conversion with helpful errors
  4. Consistent behavior: Same parsing logic for REPL and CLI
  5. Extensible: Easy to add new argument types
  6. Edge case handling: Properly handles empty strings, trailing spaces, etc.

  Example Usage

  # Before (manual parsing, breaks on spaces):
  ⚾ > defensive --hold 1,3  # Works
  ⚾ > defensive --alignment shifted left  # Breaks! (sees 'shifted' and 'left' separately)

  # After (shlex parsing, handles correctly):
  ⚾ > defensive --hold 1,3  # Still works
  ⚾ > defensive --alignment "shifted left"  # Now works with quotes!
  ⚾ > quick_play 10  # Positional arg works
  ⚾ > offensive --hit-run --bunt  # Multiple flags work